No matter the year, lore, or renovations, this classic neighborhood spot never goes out of style. Garlic knots, meatballs, chopped salad, pastas (wild mushroom or clams and linguine are always winners), and a martini or two make any night. Not ready for it to end? There’s always post-dinner drinks at speakeasy-esque The Rendition Room or The Velvet Martini Lounge next door.